my dog learned polymorphism
The moose likes Servlets and the fly likes Problem with Jayson Falkner's (onJava) Compression Filter Big Moose Saloon
  Search | Java FAQ | Recent Topics | Flagged Topics | Hot Topics | Zero Replies
Register / Login
JavaRanch » Java Forums » Java » Servlets
Bookmark "Problem with Jayson Falkner Watch "Problem with Jayson Falkner New topic

Problem with Jayson Falkner's (onJava) Compression Filter

Sam Gehouse
Ranch Hand

Joined: Jul 21, 2003
Posts: 281
I had problem using Jayson Falkner's HTTP Compression Filter ("Servlets and JavaServer pages; the J2EE Web Tier", by Jayson Falkner), as it returned warning as response is already committed when app server does a server-side forward and tries to apply the filter a second time. I was using WSAD5.1.1 and Struts 1.1. However, the behaviors is the same outside of Struts environment (meaning, while not using Struts) under WSAD 5.1.1.

I got it solved by using Sean Owne's Compression Filter ( with /* as url-pattern.

Comments from Sean Owen:

Re: Problem with *.do in Filters using Struts
Topic: Struts
Sean Owen, Nov 8, 2004 [replies:2]
"/*" is right. I think you are running into a bug in GZipFilter. I don't believe it works when the app server does a server-side forward and tries to apply the filter a second time. The recompression totally messes up the response. If I may plug my own work... I created an open-source compression filter that does not have this bug. It's also cleaner, faster and more full-featured than this old GZipFilter that people seem to use. Give it a try, along with a setting of "/*", and see if that solves your problem. PJL Compressing Filter

Additional comments from me:
I am now using Sean Owen's Filter, instead of Jayson Falkner's filter. My filter mapping is:

<filter-mapping> <filter-name>CompressingFilter</filter-name> <url-pattern>/*</url-pattern> </filter-mapping>

It works fine without throwing any Exception within Struts framework.

However, if I use /*.do, or /*.jsp, or /*.htm, it does not invoke the filter. It invokes the filter (obviously, for every page) only with /* url-pattern.

Question to Sean: Do you know why?

My Servlet does redirection to another JSP and Sean's filter is working fine within my Struts environment.

Comment to Sean: You have many assert statements like: assert config != null; You might consider removing those lines from published code. Otherwise, users have to comment those lines for the code to compile.
Sean Owen

Joined: Nov 08, 2004
Posts: 21
My reply from JGuru...

Thanks, glad it is working for you. I think you want to use the pattern "*.do" instead of "/*.do". Regarding assertions -- yes you'll need JDK 1.4 to compile the code since I'm using assertions. Let me know if it won't build in 1.4 for some reason. Or, try using the pre-compiled .jar file in the distribution. But I imagine you are trying to compile this so it runs on JDK 1.3, or earlier? I will try to modify the build so that you get a 1.3-compatible option without having to modify code. Do you need support for earlier JVMs like 1.2?
Have you checked out Aspose?
subject: Problem with Jayson Falkner's (onJava) Compression Filter
It's not a secret anymore!