I gotta tell you, I am a big fan of The Tick, but really, the live-action television show was not that good. As a fan I wanted to like it, but it just wasn't what I was hoping for. I will say that I have seen much much worse shows on TV, but I was still disappointed.
If you have one of those things for the old animated series I'll sign it. If you have one of those things that says "go back in time and make the live action tick never happen" I would sign that too. I once had a tick bumper sticker. Then the new show came out and I felt shame. The bumper sticker is now gone.