I am glad to tell that today I’ve become a member of a SCEA family. I would like to share my preparation experience, because when I was preparing your notes helped me a lot. Here comes a long-long story:)
Concerning software patters topic I’ve read MZ guide’s corresponding chapter, they are complete and just have just revise what’s in there. I haven’t used any special books as some recommend. In the first part there is not even need to know pattern’s exact implementations; you should know that pattern A is used for this and pattern B is used for that. However, I’ve also used http://sourcemaking.com/design_patterns as a reference for GoF patterns and their Java implementations.
For EJB3 I’ve read EJB3 in Action, chapters which describe its features and architecture, the implementation is out of the exam.
For JSF I’ve read Mastering JavaServer Faces, the concept is the same as with EJBs – pros, cons, architecture, comparison with JSP
For JAX-WS I’ve read SOA using Java Web Services, the same with previous, no implementation, just the theory.
There is no UML in the first part; however there are legacy connectivity topics, such as IIOP, Java IDL, JNI and so on. To get familiar with this topic I recommend you to go through the IBM’s “Java certification success, Part 4: SCEA” from here http://www.scribd.com/doc/7317384/Java-Certification-SCEA. This book is for the previous exam, however it is very well structured, I enjoyed it. I’ve also read old Mark Cade’s book, both are quite thin, only the things you need for an exam.
Exam contains a lot of scenario questions with some technologies provided. You need to select an appropriate. The hint here is not always choosing the most powerful and modern ones, but read the question carefully and address the requirements. For example if they say that they have complex queries and need performance, then you better choose DAO over JPA and so on.
After purchasing I’ve got an email from Sun with the credentials to the Assignment Database http://www.certmanager.net/sun_assignment/. From there I’ve download an assignment, it was about construction company;) It was a typical one with 4 use cases and 2 external systems to integrate.
The most valuable material for me was Chapter 9 from the new book of Humphrey Sheil, it’s freely available for download from here http://humphreysheil.blogspot.com/2009/11/book-chapter-nine-available-for.html. And I’ve learned UML a lot in the university, so the diagrams themselves were quite easy for me. I’ve used a free StarUML for UML diagrams and the whole assignment is one html page with anchor links.
Another resource for the second part is a presentation of Humphrey Sheil, it is available from here: http://www.scribd.com/doc/27655574/Humphrey-Sheil-s-SCEA-Presentation.
I hope that you’re familiar with the requirements; I’ve just highlight some aspects of my implementation. I’ve chosen a typical set of technologies – JSF/EJB3/JPA. I think it’s better to use them unless you have some special requirements in your assignment. You can then always say that I’ve chosen this because it Sun’s leading technology and it can do this, this and more. Not one size fits all, but if possible then choose them.
I’ve stated the document with background info, then I’ve put assumptions in order that assessor is familiar with them when checking later parts. Assumptions contained almost everything where multiple meaning is possible.
My class diagram contained about 20-25 classes, at first I had 30-35, but later I’ve optimized it. I didn’t show JSF Managed Beans there, however I’ve shown a controller and JSF pages (like in the book is done). This solution can be discussed but I’ve always followed that sample from the book. Why not to do like an author of an exam and assessor suggests? I’ve shown methods and major attributes, patterns and EJB types were show as stereotypes. I didn’t show design pattern implementations if it requires multiple calluses and/or interfaces. I’ve just written – this is done according to this pattern. It should be enough.
This chapter also contained some paragraphs about logging, framework, exception handling and about security. I’ve used Java EE Security for this purpose.
Component diagram was pretty simple and similar to the chapter 9’s. In this chapter I’ve also described technologies used in every layer and why I’ve chosen them. This helped me a lot when I’ve done the third part.
Deployment diagram was also close to chapter 9’s but with some additions. As it is expected I’ve presented hardware configurations and explained e.g. why I need such RAID here and another there and why here is to be more memory than there. I’ve also described test environment and client computer requirements, such as browser capabilities.
Sequence diagrams contained JSF pages, Managed Beans and so on, with methods from the class diagram used. It’s quite a large part (4 diagrams) and it makes only 16 points.
In the risk part I’ve described quite obvious risks, with obvious solutions to them. Only one of them was my-system dependent. They were technical risks; I didn’t describe not meeting some of non-functional requirements. If you need to read about the risk management, here is a good document: http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/nistpubs/800-30/sp800-30.pdf
And here comes the funniest part. I was quite lazy to finish my second part, almost 90% were done, but in order to motivate myself I’ve scheduled my third part to the end of the week and decided that I’ve complete and assignment during the week and upload it Thursday evening. But at the time I wanted to upload the system said that… I do not have an upload rights. And I should request them by mail. What on earth upload rights when I’ve paid my money and already downloaded the assignment? Don’t they think that I want to upload it after I’ve downloaded? Why this is a special favor for me?
I had no other variant rather than send an email to the mentioned address and request those rights. I’ve also sent them a checksum of a jar file, to guarantee that I haven’t changed anything. The third part was the next day and I thought they won’t be so quick to send them before the third part.
The lesson learned it that you should follow the rules and it is better to request upload rights right after you’ve got download rights. But it’s silly!
In the testing center there were no problems to take third part before the second one. The exam itself is quite simple; you have 8 questions about your architecture. They primarily address the technologies used for different tiers and the reasons for choosing them, the meeting of the NFRs and some scenario based questions, e.g. how will you system function If a bomb is thrown onto data center? It took me an hour to finish it.
I’ve received a letter with upload rights 3 days after I took the third part. What is extremely positive that it took only 5 days to check my assignment and mark it passed. Oracle optimizes Sun’s processes very well.
Once more thanks for your help and if you have any questions please feel free to ask them.
congrats! - good to know your exam was scored in 5 days. Funny I thought the process is slower now - but ofcourse you have more experience in this. May be your assignment downloading experience was worse than mine? Now, I hear it may take 10 business days for them to setup the download, even though it says 2 business days in their email. (waiting for another 6 days now )
posted 10 years ago
Perhaps I was lucky, I've got download access within 1 day (I've purchased on Friday and on Monday I've got a letter). One thing here is that local Sun office is involved here. It seems like it works this way: you order it through the website, it sends mail to the local office, they forward it to the head office and then head office sends it to you.
Congratulations and thanks for sharing your experiences.
Also thanks for the link to Humphrey Sheil blog with Chapter 9 of JEE Study Guide. Unfortunately in PDF version, which I bought from Safari Online, diagrams in this chapter are not readable (I already reported this problem to Safari Online and they promised to solve it). I compared the solution from this book and ePractize study lab for SCEA II/III, and in my opinion it is more clear. ePractize divides nearly every diagram into smaller parts (most probably because of limited space of their application), which makes them harder to read.
SCJP 1.4, SCWCD 1.4 - Hints for you, Certified Scrum Master
Did a rm -R / to find out that I lost my entire Linux installation!
posted 10 years ago
Thanks to all
Pawel, yes I also enjoyed chapter nine's solution and moreover I've looked in the properties of the PDF of my assignement and the author was Humphrey Sheil, so I decided that the books solutions should generally suit my project too.
Thanks I have 4,5 years of Java experience and some years of PHP stuff before that. The exam was not easy nor difficult. I've learned a lot, that's a good opportunity to lean, it motivates you. When you've paid the money you try to achieve the best possible results not to loose it:) When no motivation then you become lazy and don't want to learn new thing out of the scope of the work.
Is there any format for submitting design in part2.All i see in the book is that it tells that you need to have class diagram,sequence diagram,deployment diagram.
That's all.I have not yet purchased voucher for part2.
posted 10 years ago
In the end of the assignment you will get a list of diagrams and other stuff what they expect to find in your solution.
Basically it is 1x class diagram, 1x component diagram, 1x deployment diagram, 1x sequence (or collaboration) diagram per use-case (there are typically 3-4 use-cases in the assignment). Plus you need to describe hardware configurations, find 3 major risks and describe solutions for them and you have to put down all your assumptions during this project. That's all. You are free to add more diagram if you think they may help. I've also added a short summary of the task and described why I've chosen concrete patterns or frameworks.
I read your answers and it is very helpful. I wanted to ask whether you changed the multiplicity in the class diagram?
The reason for asking is in the assignment of Dreamcar Request has many PO. Did you change that?